RateGame

@zach's rating of Reds vs Phillies

@zach rated the Reds vs Phillies game 8.0 out of 10 in MLB on May 18, 2026. Final score: Reds 4 – Phillies 5. Reg. Season. Fan ratings and discussion on RateGame.

“I penciled this in as a scheduled loss with the lineup they trotted out there but Alec Bohm and Bryson Stott of all people proved me wrong. Did these guys all secretly hate Rob Thomson or does Don Mattingly being a former player carry THAT much weight? Two games above .500. Felt impossible a month ago.”

Rating published on May 19, 2026 by @zach.

Default Profile Image

@zach

creator
Watched
14d
8.0
Reds team logo4 : 5Phillies team logo
MLB • Reg. Season05/18/2026
I penciled this in as a scheduled loss with the lineup they trotted out there but Alec Bohm and Bryson Stott of all people proved me wrong. Did these guys all secretly hate Rob Thomson or does Don Mattingly being a former player carry THAT much weight? Two games above .500. Felt impossible a month ago.
0
0

Replies: